Catherine Dilts
  • About Catherine
  • Catherine Dilts - Blog
  • Rose Creek
  • Short Stories
  • Annie's Fiction
  • Survive Or Die
  • Rock Shop Mystery Series
  • About Catherine
  • Catherine Dilts - Blog
  • Rose Creek
  • Short Stories
  • Annie's Fiction
  • Survive Or Die
  • Rock Shop Mystery Series
Search by typing & pressing enter

YOUR CART

2/21/2017 4 Comments

Mystery Thriller Week - reviewing and reviewed

Picture
Only two more days of Mystery Thriller Week! My article titled I Have This Great Idea appeared on the event blog February 17.

Today on my blog, I discuss reviews. I must admit that I find both reviewing others' work, and being reviewed, to be stressful experiences.

As authors, we need reviews on major sites like Goodreads and Amazon to help our sales. We want honest reviews, and yet dread that less than stellar opinion.

I also agonize over giving reviews. I have changed my review policy and philosophy over time. Before I was published, I could be brutal. After being published, I realized how hurtful negative reviews could be, not just to an author's ego, but to their sales. For a while, I refused to review anything. I was paralyzed by fearing the damage I might do to someone's writing career by expressing my subjective reaction to his or her book.

Because that's all a review is - whether given by a professional or someone who simply reads for enjoyment. Reviews are opinions. 

I received a nice review of Stone Cold Blooded recently. You can read it here. Reviewer Mahrie G. Reid is the author of the Caleb Cove Mystery Series.

I read and reviewed Casket Cache, by Janice Richardson. and What Lies Beyond the Fence, by L. C. Hayden. Click on the title, and you can learn my opinion of these two novels. 

Reviewing doesn't have to be a school essay on literary techniques. It should be an honest expression of your reaction to a tale that entertained you. I encourage you to post reviews. (Some of my treasured readers already do - thanks!) Even if you keep it short and sweet, you'll be helping an author more than you know.

4 Comments
Jacqueline Seewald
2/22/2017 07:34:20 am

Hi Catherine,

A number of people have read my novels. I hope more of them will review these books. I always appreciate reviews. I don't know if readers realize just how important and influential their reviews are. Like you, I review many of the books I read. I review the books I enjoy. I don't review books I dislike because I know how hard we writers work on our novels.

Reply
Catherine Dilts
2/22/2017 08:16:21 am

Jacqueline, that's a good policy. All writers went to great effort to put thoughts into words. We might not enjoy a book, while it could appeal to someone else.

Reply
Elsie Hayden link
2/22/2017 08:09:42 am

I definitely agree with you about reviews. They are so important. Thanks for pointing that out!

Reply
Janice J. Richardson
2/24/2017 09:46:28 am

Like you Catherine, I have changed my attitude about reviewing books since becoming an author. If an author approaches me for an honest review, they will get one. I learned my lesson - if the book is bad I won't rate it. I will read it and let the author know privately. I am not an analyst,I am not a literary writer. I can give an honest opinion. That what our readers do, they like our books, love our books or hate them. If I review someones work, I am a reader too.

Reviews matter to an author and to degrade their work publicly is not my style. Therefore, if the book gets a 3-star review from me, it's not a great read.

99% of authors are appreciative. For that 1% that demand or expect a 4-5 star review, I let them know they will not get a rating or review from me.until I have read the book and given it a chance.

It happened once - an author was not happy with my low rating and review and kept pestering me to read the rest of the series. I refused. The author defended their work and could not accept that it was substandard. If I could pull that rating, I would.

As for my work, I respect and appreciate the time a blogger/reviewer takes to read and review my book(s). If it is a 2 star rating in their opinion, they they need to be able to give that opinion without my interference. That's how I learn and grow as an author, constructive criticism matters as much as a positive feedback.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Subscribe to this blog:

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.